-
Posts
933 -
Joined
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Store
Everything posted by Norm_uk
-
As Austin Mitchell once observed, "The basic law of politics is that to be right too soon is to be wrong." The wisdom of the crowd is not necessarily wisdom at all. People can be remarkably quick to ridicule those who question accepted assumptions, and remarkably slow to reconsider them until the consequences become impossible to ignore. The story of Noah rather comes to mind!
-
"Self-pitying right-wing victimhood" is a curious way to begin a serious discussion. It's a judgement about the person making an argument, not an answer to it. You're quite right that several major British newspaper proprietors lean right. I never suggested otherwise. But media ownership, editorial policy and the political views of journalists and are three different things. The Reuters Institute's 2025 study found that 77% of British journalists surveyed identified as left-leaning. It also acknowledged that many national newspapers have right-leaning editorial lines. Both observations can be true. Likewise, broadcasters being required to demonstrate impartiality doesn't establish that they invariably achieve it. We can reasonably disagree about how much these factors influence reporting. But suggesting the only explanations for my observation are ignorance, dishonesty or extreme-right politics rather neatly illustrates my original point about attributing motives and character rather than examining arguments.
-
Indeed, and I never suggested otherwise. The UNHCR confirms that 65% of refugees remain in neighbouring countries. Your examples, particularly Lebanon, actually illustrate the enormous pressures that large refugee populations can place on host societies. But that doesn't answer my question. What numbers should Britain accept, if any and at what cost, and with what consideration for housing, public services, taxpayers and the wishes of existing communities? The House of Commons Public Accounts Committee reported asylum expenditure of £4.9 billion in 2024–25, including £2.7 billion on accommodation alone. These are hardly insignificant consequences, especially in a nation of out of control public spending and lacklustre growth. Surely the experience of countries such as Lebanon strengthens the case for properly funded regional protection, where safe and practical, rather than assuming distant Western settlement is always preferable. My argument concerns the most effective use of resources, the capacity of receiving societies and democratic accountability. None of those questions is answered simply by observing that most refugees remain nearer home.
-
I suspect we agree on many of the symptoms: poor productivity, an ageing population and strained public finances. Where we differ is on the causes and remedies. I don't accept that the choice is simply to work until we die or continually import younger populations with permanent settlement and citizenship. Temporary labour migration is another option. More fundamentally, why not address our declining birth rates? Housing affordability, family taxation, economic security and a culture that genuinely values marriage, honours and celebrates motherhood and children instead of often disparaging more traditional families would be a start. We've created an economy where many women must work whether they wish to or not, while claiming to celebrate choice. There's also an economic incentive for employers to favour larger labour pools. The Migration Advisory Committee has questioned whether some shortages reflect poor pay rather than insufficient workers. Interestingly, Amazon-owned Whole Foods was reported to have used workforce diversity as one factor in assessing unionisation risks. Immigration can meet immediate shortages, but it isn't a substitute for a hyper individualistic pleasure seeking culture, nor for better family policy, investment in our own workforce or addressing the difficulties of integration and social cohesion instead of shouting any criticism of the outcomes as comparible to mid 20th century Germans. We've become accustomed to treating the consequences of our economic and cultural policies as inevitable, rather than questioning those policies themselves. This seems to suggest we also have a generally bad leadership problem, and a population that is not particularly confident in itself. We agree on much of the diagnosis. It's the treatment where we differ.
-
I think there's a wider institutional issue here. Surveys suggest that British journalists and academics lean heavily to the left. That doesn't mean everyone shares the same views, but it does influence what's considered acceptable opinion. When certain ideas become institutional orthodoxy, those who challenge them can find themselves defending their motives and character rather than their arguments. It's an Overton window at work, and I suspect it partly explains why some political ideas and parties receive rather different treatment from others.
-
Western interventions may contribute to displacement in some cases, but many asylum claims also come from countries without active wars, and not every conflict is the West's responsibility. And it is noticed repeatedly that people are passing many safe nations to arrive in the EU and UK. Even where Western policy has contributed, it doesn't follow that Britain must accept large numbers regardless of the consequences for housing, public services, taxpayers and public safety. Where safe and practical, supporting refugees closer to their homelands may help considerably more people at lower cost, while avoiding unnecessary cultural dislocation. And if some arrivals understandably resent the countries they blame for their circumstances, surely that strengthens the case for careful security vetting and integration, not abandoning either compassion or national interest. Could all that be true while strongly criticising US foreign policy?
-
The growth is welcome, and I don't dispute the figures. But headline GDP tells us relatively little about how ordinary households are faring. Inflation was still 3.5% in September, and although housing affordability has improved recently, the average English home still costs 7.6 times median annual earnings. For younger people hoping to establish financial independence, that's a considerable obstacle that wasn't there a generation or two ago. Public finances are another concern. The OBR forecasts around £353 billion in welfare spending this financial year, including pensions, alongside approximately £124 billion in debt interest. These are substantial commitments that growth won't affect much without serious rethinking of welfare and debt. I suspect we agree both Britain needs stronger productivity, better economic prospects and a more business-friendly environment, although we'd disagree about the remedies or causes of the current problems
-
I'm a great believer in aesthetics (a thing to say repeatedly in the StockingsHQ forums!). Beauty is as important to human wellbeing as material prosperity, despite modern political theory's obsession with the ever-present "socio-economic" explanation. I suspect much of today's psychological malaise is partly attributable to decades of ugly architecture, dreary urban planning, clothing and art. Not the sole cause, obviously, but hardly irrelevant. We all moan about one small aspect of it here all the time - the decline of dress standards. I admire aspects of Schopenhauer's thinking, particularly his approach to debate. But I'm not inclined to set myself on fire to keep my neighbours warm. His philosophy has its merits, and its limits.
-
I have just read some of the responses on this forum. I think there's a rather Schopenhauerian observation to be made. There is something wonderfully self-defeating about trying to establish another person's intellectual inferiority by abandoning reason and resorting to ridicule. One may succeed in making the opponent look foolish, but only at the cost of demonstrating one's own foolishness. And that is perhaps why these forum exchanges so frequently descend into stalemate. Each participant becomes increasingly concerned with demonstrating the other's defects, while providing ever more material for the other to do exactly the same. The argument becomes its own evidence of the problem.
-
I agree education and the media have contributed considerably, although blaming everything on outside manipulation overlooks decades of ideological influence through our own institutions and media. So much of our culture now comes from entertainment, rewarding emotion, outrage and tribal allegiance over reason. Neither left nor right is immune to that. The reflexive anti-Americanism is interesting. There's plenty to criticise about American policy and culture, yet the US, with a considerably smaller population than the EU, has a substantially larger economy and has outperformed it for decades. That doesn't make America a model to copy blindly, but perhaps outcomes deserve more attention than ideological loyalties. My greater concern is a British establishment that increasingly seems to regard our own people as incapable of sustaining a functioning society without continuous large-scale immigration and dilution of native European identity. Not merely to perform work supposedly beneath us (an uncomfortable echo of the old slave-owning mentality) but increasingly as though we lack the talent, culture or moral standing to sustain our own civilisation. It's hardly surprising that resentment is growing among communities who feel their concerns about identity, economic security and law and order are dismissed. Denunciation is not social cohesion, and repeatedly treating disagreement as hatred is no substitute for governing well. I have little interest in importing America's Republican-versus-Democrat divisions into British politics, or subordinating British interests to Washington, Brussels or any fashionable globalist ideology. I'd rather see a country confident enough to pursue its own interests, question inherited assumptions in the post WWII era and judge institutions by what they actually produce. A society that cannot discuss its problems without turning opponents into enemies is storing up considerably greater problems for itself.
-
Agreed. The British press has always enjoyed sensationalism, but modern media has industrialised it. Emotion attracts attention far more effectively than reason, and public debate increasingly resembles entertainment. Of course, the allegations against Brand and others deserve proper investigation and reporting, and where wrongdoing is established, justice for the victims. Cultural explanations excuse no individual. But there's an uncomfortable wider question. We've spent sixty years dismantling social and sexual restraints, normalising pornography, prostitution and the pursuit of personal gratification, while dismissing all inherited standards as repression. Brand himself has spoken of his early introduction to pornography and prostitution. What sort of behaviour do we imagine such a culture encourages? Previous generations were hardly free of vice of course, but they at least recognised virtue, restraint and courtesy as things society ought to cultivate publically. We've thrown away many of those expectations and seem astonished when the consequences aren't entirely pleasant. The Romans called it bread and circuses. The circuses are thriving, certainly, but perhaps we should also examine the civilisation producing the spectacle. We shouldn't be surprised by the harvest when we're unwilling to discuss what was sown as a society - from sensationalist media to the consequences of widespread normalised vice on marriage, relationships, children and mental health.